Yes and no. You’ll need to have a valid explanation for adding it… Why do you need to access the shared filesystem?
2 Likes
same problem here please solve this problem
2 Likes
… and not for the app developer either.
So again:
2 Likes
And for the last time: There is NO problem (at least as long as Kodular is targeting API 29).
4 Likes
@bodymindpower thank you so much for letting us know that we don’t have to panic and just relax because we are using API 29. Thanks once again, you are the best
5 Likes
Exactly
2 Likes
To take it account:
Requirements for updates to existing apps
From November 2021 , updates to existing apps will be required to target API level 30 or above and adjust for behavioral changes in Android 11. Existing apps that are not receiving updates are unaffected and can continue to be downloaded from the Play Store.
This is known and has already been communicated e.g. here:
My application doesn’t need to access storage on the customer’s phone, can I edit MANIFEST through Kodular?
Is it possible to edit the manifest through Kodular?
No, and there is no reason at all for that.
We can’t ignore it, because in all cases kodular continue to make unnecessary permissions in the manifest file, i don’t know why!
For example, try to create a new project and use just a simple button in your screen, then try to export the apk and look in the manifest file (with apk editor) , you’ll find WRITE permission and externalLegacyStorage, …! Even with API 30 , google will ask you: why you keep this Legacy in your manifest? For what?
And of course, because we can’t remove unnecessary permission that kodular makes 
No, even if you make a simple button in your project you will find this Legacy in the manifest , pfffff !
Today i tried to look for that, i created a new project in kodular, i used only a simple button in the screen without any component,
The surprise !!! When i opened the apk with apk efitor i found “externalLegacyStorage” in the manifest !!! But why ?
I found also a WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE permission !!!
A lot of permissions just for a simple button?
Kodular has to fix this problem.
- No,
WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGEpermission is NOT declared in theManifestof an empty project (with only one button). - Yes,
android:requestLegacyExternalStorage="true"is declared in theManifestof each project, as I already said here:
To prevent access problems to the external storage with Android 11 devices.
As I already said (→ #15): targetSdkVersion = 29: requestLegacyExternalStorage → works.
No !!!
No, only these:
<uses-permission android:name="android.permission.INTERNET"/>
<uses-permission android:name="android.permission.ACCESS_NETWORK_STATE"/>
<uses-permission android:name="android.permission.ACCESS_WIFI_STATE"/>
and these (non-dangerous permissions) are always declared.
No.
5 Likes
please tell clearly what i should do ?
Nothing…
(as of now )
3 Likes
then when we will update our app?
I think everything necessary on this topic has already been said.
2 Likes
