Extension list permission

[Vivekjain]

I made a list of extension

List Of Active Extension For App Inventor

Please tell me if any legal term am I missing
If not close the topic and unlist

[Taifun]

what exactly is a “list of active extensions for App Inventor”?
you are listing 4 extensions?

is this something like an extensions directory?
if yes, see here App Inventor Extensions | Pura Vida Apps which lists more than 625 extensions…

Taifun

[Vivekjain]

I am adding
Will be updated shortly
I will add new extension daily

[Vivekjain]

@Taifun

4 extensions

Now 8

[Vivekjain]

Is I missing any legal terms

[Peter (Moderator)]

May i ask why you make such a list? The list from @Taifun is the most extensive there is. Why would people use your list?

[yusufcihan]

Looks like people wants to have own extension directory too.

[Taifun]

@Vivekjain

Now 8

it seems to get more and more popular to put together an extensions directory?
you might want to read this

List of extensions for App Inventor and its distributions

The list https://community.kodular.io/t/index-of-available-extensions/23/2 contains currently about 150 extensions. Taifun’s website https://puravidaapps.com/extensions.php lists currently more than 625 extensions. So this is always my first choice when looking for an extension. https://community.appinventor.mit.edu/t/hay-all-there-is-already-a-website-for-extensions-its-called-devs-extension/11074/14?u=anke

There is already an encyclopedic extensions directory available, which is here
App Inventor Extensions | Pura Vida Apps, which lists currently more than 625 extensions. I’m collecting links to available extensions already since the extension feature was introduced in App Inventor in 2016.

As you just said, you are listing currently 8 extensions…

Questions:

• How do you want to find links to extensions without copying the links from my site? And do you think, this would be morally and ethically correct? I don’t think so…
• Are you ready to keep up to date with your list and this not only for a few weeks or months but for years?

Taifun

[Vivekjain]

@Taifun

How do you want to find links to extensions without copying the links from my site? And do you think, this would be morally and ethically correct? I don’t think so…

According to me you are saying I am trying to copying your list so it’s false I am reading and updating

[Vivekjain]

@Taifun

Are you ready to keep up to date with your list and this not only for a few weeks or months but for years?

I will try

[Vivekjain]

@Peter

Why would people use your list?

I did not say people to my list
I am creating it for me for a project and I only asked if I am legally doing right
And if people want to use use it it’s public but mainly list is for me

[Vivekjain]

@yusufcihan

Looks like people wants to have own extension directory too.

For my work then yes

[Vivekjain]

@Taifun

I’m collecting links to available extensions already since the extension feature was introduced in App Inventor in 2016.

I respect your hard work always if you want I will not make it public

[yusufcihan]

@Vivekjain

I am legally doing right

Legally?

If you don’t post direct links to the extension then you won’t have problems.

But ethically?

Then no.

[Vivekjain]

I did not post direct links

[Vivekjain]

@yusufcihan

But ethically?

Then no.

What this means

[yusufcihan]

@Vivekjain

For my work then yes

For which work?

You know you can’t earn money by sharing our extension links if you plan that.

@Vivekjain

What this means

It is wrong as behavior.

[Vivekjain]

@yusufcihan

You know you can’t earn money by sharing our extension links if you plan that.

Never I am Indian and never try to eat someone money

[Vivekjain]

@yusufcihan

For which work?

For a project can tell you name

[Vivekjain]

@yusufcihan

It is wrong as behavior.

Why it is wrong